People tell me there is no evidence in any madhabs of wearing pants above ankles. the beard they say that Maliki madhab only has a goatee or hair around mouth and chin and not whole beard as minimum
Question
Someone told me that nowhere in any of the four madhabs is that we have to wear our pants or izar above our ankles. Is this true? If it is then but there are hadith which say to do this, so I am confused whether we should do taqleed or what? As well as the beard they say that Maliki madhab only has a goatee or hair around mouth and chin and not whole beard as a minimum, so what is a maliki to do when discussing the beard according to hadith we must not shave so what is this I am confused whether to do taqleed of the madhab or follow hadith.
Answer
The assumption of this 'someone' is inaccurate.
The prohibition of this deed according to the Hanafi Madhab could be found in Shaami vol.6 pg.351 and Fataawa Hindiyya vol.5 pg.333
Among the Shaafi'ee, great scholars such as Imaam Nawawiy and Haafiz ibn Hajar (RA) have also mentioned the severity of this deed. (Sharh Muslim and Fathul Baari)
For the ruling regarding other Madhaahib, we suggest you consult the respective Ulama.
We are unable to confirm the ruling of the Maaliki Madhab regarding the length of the beard as mentioned by yourself. However, the ruling of the following Maaliki scholars apparently contradict your statement: 1. Qaadhi Abdul-Wahhaab (RA) in al-Ma'oonah (vol.3 pg.1706)
2. Imaam Abul-Waleed al-Baaji (RA) in al-Muntaqa (vol.1 pg.266) 3. Ibn Rushd (RA) in al-Bayaan wa Tahseel (vol.17 pg.3391)
4. Al-Qurtubi (RA) in al-Mufhim (vol.1 pg.512 - 513)
5. Muhammad ibn Khulfha al-Ubbi in Ikmaal-ul-Ikmaal-lil-Muslim
After studying the above, you would note that the Madhaahib of Fiqh conform to Hadith. Hence, there is no reason for your confusion.
We still advise that you consult authentic Maaliki Ulama on this subject.
and Allah Ta'ala Knows Best
Moulana Muhammad ibn Moulana Haroon Abbassommar
FACULTY OF SPECIALTY IN HADITH
CHECKED AND APPROVED: Mufti Ebrahim Desai
Fatawa SA is an independent, read-only index of fatawa already published by Darul Iftaa Mahmudiyyah (AskImam). It is not a fatwa service. For your own situation, ask the issuing Darul Ifta directly.